Failure: The Secret Ingredient in Scientific Discovery

Lexile: 1120 | Grade: 9

Passage

In school, failure often feels like the opposite of success. A bad grade, a wrong answer, a missed step—these can be discouraging moments. But in science, failure is not only expected—it’s essential. Many of the greatest breakthroughs in history happened because something went wrong.

Take Thomas Edison, for example. Before inventing the light bulb, he tested over a thousand different materials to find the right filament. When asked about these failed attempts, Edison reportedly said, 'I have not failed. I've just found 10,000 ways that won't work.' This mindset wasn’t about avoiding mistakes—it was about learning from them.

In scientific research, failure is often the beginning of insight. A failed experiment can reveal a hidden variable or expose an assumption that needs to be questioned. When the unexpected happens, it opens the door to asking new questions. These moments of uncertainty are not setbacks—they are stepping stones.

Even in space exploration, failure has guided progress. The Mars Climate Orbiter, launched by NASA in 1998, failed because engineers used two different measurement systems—metric and imperial. The mistake caused the spacecraft to crash into the planet. While the mission was lost, the lesson was not. NASA improved its systems, communication, and engineering checks as a direct result.

Science is not about getting everything right the first time. It’s a process of trial, error, and revision. The willingness to experiment, reflect, and try again is what drives discovery forward. In this way, science mirrors life itself—where growth often comes not from perfection, but from persistence.

For students, this can be an empowering message. Failure doesn’t define your intelligence or ability. In fact, learning how to handle failure with curiosity and resilience may be one of the most valuable skills you can develop—not just in science, but in everything you pursue.

Questions

Q1: What is the central message of the passage?

  • A. Scientists should avoid failure at all costs.
  • B. Failure in school and science means the same thing.
  • C. Failure is a powerful part of learning and discovery in science.
  • D. Only famous inventors benefit from making mistakes.

Q2: How does the example of Thomas Edison support the author's point?

  • A. It shows that Edison never failed at anything.
  • B. It demonstrates that Edison avoided scientific experiments.
  • C. It illustrates how persistence and learning from failure can lead to success.
  • D. It proves that most inventors don’t need many experiments to succeed.

Q3: What lesson did NASA learn from the failure of the Mars Climate Orbiter?

  • A. That Mars missions are too dangerous to attempt
  • B. That space missions should avoid using technology
  • C. That small mistakes can have large consequences, and systems need to be improved
  • D. That imperial measurements are better than metric ones

Q4: Which statement best reflects the author’s view on how failure relates to personal growth?

  • A. Failure should be avoided in order to succeed.
  • B. Mistakes show that a person is not intelligent.
  • C. Experiencing failure can build curiosity and resilience.
  • D. Success only comes to those who never fail.

Q5: What does the phrase 'Failure is not only expected—it’s essential' suggest about the scientific process?

  • A. Scientists are not trained well enough.
  • B. Mistakes should be ignored during experiments.
  • C. Failure is a normal and necessary part of discovering new knowledge.
  • D. Success in science is based entirely on luck.

Printable Comprehension Practice

Visit us at https://readbuddies.com to practice interactively, track your progress, and explore more comprehension passages.

Answers & Reasoning

Q1: What is the central message of the passage?

✅ Correct Answer: C

💡 Reasoning: The passage emphasizes that failure leads to progress and deeper understanding, especially in scientific work.

Q2: How does the example of Thomas Edison support the author's point?

✅ Correct Answer: C

💡 Reasoning: Edison's story reinforces the idea that failure is part of the process, not a sign of defeat.

Q3: What lesson did NASA learn from the failure of the Mars Climate Orbiter?

✅ Correct Answer: C

💡 Reasoning: The passage explains how a measurement error caused the mission to fail, leading NASA to improve their processes.

Q4: Which statement best reflects the author’s view on how failure relates to personal growth?

✅ Correct Answer: C

💡 Reasoning: The author encourages readers to see failure as a chance to grow stronger and think more deeply.

Q5: What does the phrase 'Failure is not only expected—it’s essential' suggest about the scientific process?

✅ Correct Answer: C

💡 Reasoning: The phrase highlights that failure is a valuable step in scientific thinking and should be embraced, not feared.